Mrs. Sgt. T likes the romantic comedies. So do I, but not as much as her. She loves them enough to want to own them. But not all of them. And I can't figure out why she likes some but not others. I'll think I have it figured out, and in a store sometime I'll point to one that, in my mind, is just like one
we own, and she'll say, no, you don't get it at all. And I don't.
So we have a lot to talk about whenever we watch one. Like, we just watched Runaway Bride, which I'd never seen all the way through, even though I've walked through the room several times, it feels like, while she was watching it. This time I watched it all, and when it was over I asked her why she liked it. Like, doesn't the misogyny bother her? I mean, the Richard Gere character starts out by saying these heinous things about women in general, and about the Julia Roberts character in particular, and sure he loses his job, but on the level of the movie where it counts he never has to pay for it. He's never humiliated, never has to apologize or say he was wrong. Sure he gets away with it because Richard Gere's so damned charming, but meanwhile the Julia Roberts character basically has to go through this long bout of self-searching where she realizes that, yes, she has caused all her lovers, and even friends, to suffer because of her lack of self-awareness - that basically everything the Richard Gere character said about her was true except for the malice. He never has to humble himself to find happiness and true love, but she does.
To which Mrs. Sgt T said, you're making the mistake of assuming he has anything to do with it. He's irrelevant. The story isn't about him. It's a story about her - about the female viewer, if you will - and her own self-searching; he's basically just an externalization of her own self-critical voice. The only journey that matters in the film is hers. It's not that the man gets off scot-free, it's that he doesn't have any meaningful existence beyond her.
I never thought of that.
Bond: It's what keeps me alive. Natalya: It's what keeps you alone.
Tuesday, September 10, 2013
Monday, September 9, 2013
Short Term 12 (2013)
The more I think about this film the more I find not to like. A carefully multicultural cast of
characters that nevertheless manages to make the attractive young white people into saviors. The way the lone black male among the Troubled Kids is held up first as a potential gangsta (only to be neutralized into a poetic rapper). The way the elderly Latino couple are held up as exemplars of abundant family love. The way the head of the facility is shown as naive and out-of-touch, because, you know, this is America and we hate intellectuals. The way the most vulnerable of the kids literally wraps himself in the American flag at the end of the picture... The film's full of noxious clichés, in other words, and the more you think about the film the more obvious they become.
That said, I really enjoyed the movie in the moment. Expertly paced, shot, and acted, with characters that, while on the screen, seem to transcend their clichés. And politically, unlike a more notorious recent troubled-school-system film, this one doesn't propose any facetious, destructive "answers." It's impossible to come away from the film without the impression that we're underfunding our social safety net, allowing it to depend on the heroic efforts of those who choose to work for it for far too little money (which is why the film's decision to bash the administrator is so disappointing). But how to fix it, when the real problem runs bone-deep in our society? It's a commentary on America (which is why the flag at the end was so annoying - if you need to be bashed over the head with that message at the end of the movie, chances are you don't care anyway).
Worth seeing. But preaching to the choir. Is that a contradiction in terms?
characters that nevertheless manages to make the attractive young white people into saviors. The way the lone black male among the Troubled Kids is held up first as a potential gangsta (only to be neutralized into a poetic rapper). The way the elderly Latino couple are held up as exemplars of abundant family love. The way the head of the facility is shown as naive and out-of-touch, because, you know, this is America and we hate intellectuals. The way the most vulnerable of the kids literally wraps himself in the American flag at the end of the picture... The film's full of noxious clichés, in other words, and the more you think about the film the more obvious they become.
That said, I really enjoyed the movie in the moment. Expertly paced, shot, and acted, with characters that, while on the screen, seem to transcend their clichés. And politically, unlike a more notorious recent troubled-school-system film, this one doesn't propose any facetious, destructive "answers." It's impossible to come away from the film without the impression that we're underfunding our social safety net, allowing it to depend on the heroic efforts of those who choose to work for it for far too little money (which is why the film's decision to bash the administrator is so disappointing). But how to fix it, when the real problem runs bone-deep in our society? It's a commentary on America (which is why the flag at the end was so annoying - if you need to be bashed over the head with that message at the end of the movie, chances are you don't care anyway).
Worth seeing. But preaching to the choir. Is that a contradiction in terms?
Saturday, September 7, 2013
Gil Evans: The Complete Pacific Jazz Sessions
The Complete Pacific Jazz Sessions is a 2006 CD reissue of two Gil Evans albums on one disc: New Bottle Old Wine from 1958 and Great Jazz Standards from 1959. The skinny is that they were his second and third records as a leader, a capacity he'd been able to assume due to the prominence he'd achieved through his collaborations with Miles Davis, beginning in earnest in 1957.
New Bottle Old Wine fairly closely follows the model of Evans's first album with Davis. This record,
too, is essentially built around one soloist, in this case Cannonball Adderley. It's Adderley's instrumental voice that dominates the recordings, Adderley's improvisational sensibilities that provide the heart. It's a fine record, though, don't get me wrong; Evans's style as an arranger is fully realized at this point, and he's doing fine things with these tunes. They're carefully chosen to guide the listener through the history of jazz from W.C. Handy and Jelly Roll Morton up to Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie, and as arranged by Evans it all sounds of a piece, utterly modern, and even highbrow. This is dry-martini music.
Great Jazz Standards opens things up a bit. Solo duties are spread around among a number of players, notably Steve Lacy, Johnny Coles, and Budd Johnson, on a number of instruments, and Gil's own piano plays a small but key role on a few tracks. And, it could
just be me, but the result (and this is strange to say, when Cannonball leaves such a mark on the first record) on the second result is more emotional, more moving. My favorite track so far is the second record's opener, the Bix Beiderbecke number "Davenport Blues."
Shadows of Treme, sure. And at this point any trumpeter waking up in Gil Evans's bed is going to be suspected of Miles Davis, but Coles makes his own case pretty quick, achieving a singing, broad, magnanimous tone that Miles just didn't use. But it's Gil we're here to hear, right? And he delivers, with a setting that alternates between moaning very reminiscent of '20s hot jazz sonorities and the muted-horn, odd-woodwind murmuring you expect from him. And it all adds up to a deeply moving, authentically felt blues. This is the olive in your martini.
New Bottle Old Wine fairly closely follows the model of Evans's first album with Davis. This record,
too, is essentially built around one soloist, in this case Cannonball Adderley. It's Adderley's instrumental voice that dominates the recordings, Adderley's improvisational sensibilities that provide the heart. It's a fine record, though, don't get me wrong; Evans's style as an arranger is fully realized at this point, and he's doing fine things with these tunes. They're carefully chosen to guide the listener through the history of jazz from W.C. Handy and Jelly Roll Morton up to Charlie Parker and Dizzy Gillespie, and as arranged by Evans it all sounds of a piece, utterly modern, and even highbrow. This is dry-martini music.
Great Jazz Standards opens things up a bit. Solo duties are spread around among a number of players, notably Steve Lacy, Johnny Coles, and Budd Johnson, on a number of instruments, and Gil's own piano plays a small but key role on a few tracks. And, it could
just be me, but the result (and this is strange to say, when Cannonball leaves such a mark on the first record) on the second result is more emotional, more moving. My favorite track so far is the second record's opener, the Bix Beiderbecke number "Davenport Blues."
Shadows of Treme, sure. And at this point any trumpeter waking up in Gil Evans's bed is going to be suspected of Miles Davis, but Coles makes his own case pretty quick, achieving a singing, broad, magnanimous tone that Miles just didn't use. But it's Gil we're here to hear, right? And he delivers, with a setting that alternates between moaning very reminiscent of '20s hot jazz sonorities and the muted-horn, odd-woodwind murmuring you expect from him. And it all adds up to a deeply moving, authentically felt blues. This is the olive in your martini.
Wednesday, September 4, 2013
The Aubrey/Maturin series
I read the whole Aubrey/Maturin series, basically straight through in a few weeks' time, something like ten years ago. (Yes, it was the movie that made me aware of them.) It was one of the most engrossing and enjoyable reading experiences I've had, one of those experiences of utter literary transport that I live for. But it took, as I say, weeks out of my life: the books are impossible to put down once you start one, and each one ends, not on a cliffhanger, but on the barest of resolutions of only the most superficial of the plotlines, so that you have to get twenty or thirty pages into the next volume before you feel able to even pause for a while. So I haven't reread them since. But now I'm halfway through the series again.
And I'm reading them far too obsessively to blog them individually, or even collectively in a coherent fashion. Let me make just two observations.
First, the obvious one (given what I've just written). The twenty completed volumes are, taken together, a masterpiece of popular fiction. And I use that latter term guardedly: they're popular fiction in that they inhabit a recognizable genre, and consciously, intentionally offer many of the traditional pleasures of popular fiction, compulsive readability not least among them. But they're deep beyond any of the censure that may still (but probably doesn't anymore) attach to the term "popular fiction." The prose is not just beautiful but challenging; the characterizations are as subtle and complete as anything I've encountered in literature; and the themes are as thoughtful and thought-provoking as you could ask for.
To wit (and this is my second observation): I think the books' big theme is Tories vs. Whigs. Not in the narrow sense of the two parties that dominated British parliamentary politics at the time of the Napoleonic Wars: certainly those parties are mentioned by name, and some of the issues over which they argued are brought in. But this is done with O'Brian's characteristic subtlety, so that for a reader like me who's not an expert in the period it's easy to miss them - an occasional mention of rotten boroughs suggests a great deal, but doesn't spell much out.
Because what O'Brian's more interested in is Toryism and Whiggishness as temperaments, as fundamental approaches to life. Conservative vs. liberal, to use today's terms. Broadly speaking he gives us Jack Aubrey of the Royal Navy as an example of the Tory approach - Aubrey embodies the Navy's adherence to tradition, to tried-and-true ways, and its abhorrence of innovation (the word itself is used as a term of opprobrium on several occasions in the books). Stephen Maturin counterbalances him as an example of Whig values, I suppose - being Irish-Catalan, he's never described in terms of English politics, but he embraces innovation, scientific theory, progress on all fronts.
What lends these broad tensions resonance is the series' Napoleonic Wars setting. Maturin and many other characters who find themselves now fighting Napoleon privately find the values asserted by the French Revolution appealing: Maturin was a revolutionary in his younger days, and opposes Napoleon not because he's French, and not because he threatens England, but because he betrayed the Revolution's ideals. The books therefore become an ongoing, unresolvable, but strenuously argued debate over questions of authority and how it should be constituted and exercised.
What makes the books so satisfying, however, is O'Brian's penchant for complicating every character he sketches. We become accustomed to the idea of Aubrey as the conservative naval officer who learned to sail by instinct and is content to do things the way they've always been done because they've always been done that way - because tradition is its own authority - but then in middle age he suddenly develops a passion for mathematics, for understanding the theoretical basis for his sailing instincts, and in fact we realize that he spends just as much time bucking tradition as buckling under to it. He thinks of himself as a Tory but in many ways he's a Whig. Meanwhile Maturin is a vocal opponent of Naval conservatism, ridiculing all its old ways with a variable degree of affection, but in his own profession as physician he's an unquestioning adherent of bloodletting as a virtual panacea; on a less comic note, we're often reminded that, despite his revolutionary youth, he has an aristocratic background and is no more a friend to democracy (another word always used derogatorily in the books) than is Aubrey.
What O'Brian is giving us in these books, then, is characters caught between fundamental human impulses toward stasis on the one hand and change on the other, at a moment when each impulse has been given clear historical manifestation, when the positions have become polarized to the point of bloodshed, but characters who themselves refuse to become polarized, because they themselves are not comfortable at either pole. They are, actually, perfectly Cold War books, and I think I love them for a lot of the same reasons that I love Le Carré's George Smiley books.
And I'm reading them far too obsessively to blog them individually, or even collectively in a coherent fashion. Let me make just two observations.
First, the obvious one (given what I've just written). The twenty completed volumes are, taken together, a masterpiece of popular fiction. And I use that latter term guardedly: they're popular fiction in that they inhabit a recognizable genre, and consciously, intentionally offer many of the traditional pleasures of popular fiction, compulsive readability not least among them. But they're deep beyond any of the censure that may still (but probably doesn't anymore) attach to the term "popular fiction." The prose is not just beautiful but challenging; the characterizations are as subtle and complete as anything I've encountered in literature; and the themes are as thoughtful and thought-provoking as you could ask for.
To wit (and this is my second observation): I think the books' big theme is Tories vs. Whigs. Not in the narrow sense of the two parties that dominated British parliamentary politics at the time of the Napoleonic Wars: certainly those parties are mentioned by name, and some of the issues over which they argued are brought in. But this is done with O'Brian's characteristic subtlety, so that for a reader like me who's not an expert in the period it's easy to miss them - an occasional mention of rotten boroughs suggests a great deal, but doesn't spell much out.
Because what O'Brian's more interested in is Toryism and Whiggishness as temperaments, as fundamental approaches to life. Conservative vs. liberal, to use today's terms. Broadly speaking he gives us Jack Aubrey of the Royal Navy as an example of the Tory approach - Aubrey embodies the Navy's adherence to tradition, to tried-and-true ways, and its abhorrence of innovation (the word itself is used as a term of opprobrium on several occasions in the books). Stephen Maturin counterbalances him as an example of Whig values, I suppose - being Irish-Catalan, he's never described in terms of English politics, but he embraces innovation, scientific theory, progress on all fronts.
What lends these broad tensions resonance is the series' Napoleonic Wars setting. Maturin and many other characters who find themselves now fighting Napoleon privately find the values asserted by the French Revolution appealing: Maturin was a revolutionary in his younger days, and opposes Napoleon not because he's French, and not because he threatens England, but because he betrayed the Revolution's ideals. The books therefore become an ongoing, unresolvable, but strenuously argued debate over questions of authority and how it should be constituted and exercised.
What makes the books so satisfying, however, is O'Brian's penchant for complicating every character he sketches. We become accustomed to the idea of Aubrey as the conservative naval officer who learned to sail by instinct and is content to do things the way they've always been done because they've always been done that way - because tradition is its own authority - but then in middle age he suddenly develops a passion for mathematics, for understanding the theoretical basis for his sailing instincts, and in fact we realize that he spends just as much time bucking tradition as buckling under to it. He thinks of himself as a Tory but in many ways he's a Whig. Meanwhile Maturin is a vocal opponent of Naval conservatism, ridiculing all its old ways with a variable degree of affection, but in his own profession as physician he's an unquestioning adherent of bloodletting as a virtual panacea; on a less comic note, we're often reminded that, despite his revolutionary youth, he has an aristocratic background and is no more a friend to democracy (another word always used derogatorily in the books) than is Aubrey.
What O'Brian is giving us in these books, then, is characters caught between fundamental human impulses toward stasis on the one hand and change on the other, at a moment when each impulse has been given clear historical manifestation, when the positions have become polarized to the point of bloodshed, but characters who themselves refuse to become polarized, because they themselves are not comfortable at either pole. They are, actually, perfectly Cold War books, and I think I love them for a lot of the same reasons that I love Le Carré's George Smiley books.
Thursday, August 29, 2013
Yamamoto Naoki: Ashita mata denwa suru yo
Here's your literary, artistic, interesting, worthwhile erotica in manga form. Right here. It's a collection of short stories by Yamamoto Naoki 山本直樹 called Ashita mata denwa suru yo 明日また電話するよ (I'll call you again tomorrow); came out in 2008, but the stories were originally published between 1995 and 2002, in various venues.
I'm new to Yamamoto, but I always see his stuff in the cool corners of the manga floors of the biggest bookstores - that corner by the elevator in the basement of the Ikebukuro Junkudo - I bought this purely on a flyer. Sometimes you get lucky.
It's fine stuff. It's sexy, sure, but also by turns creepy, nostalgic, funny, wistful, hard-boiled, satirical, socially engaged, and even innocent. There's always two or three things going on alongside the wet stuff; usually something to make the wet stuff even wetter, and something else to make it bone dry.
The writing's great, and the art rises to the occasion, too. He's more daring, or is allowed to be freer, than most artists who draw this kind of stuff for mass-market publications in Japan, but what makes his wet stuff work is, of course, not just their cunning lubricity, but his sensitive and sure touch with everything else in the visual plane. His framing, his composition, his line and shade, are all masterful; and he experiments. There's one story in here told entirely in long-focus and wide-frame, same angle, panel after panel, like a movie camera set up and turned on and left; it's not a trick he came up with (I've seen it in Tezuka, for example), but neither is it a common one, and he uses it well.
It's adult in every sense of the word.
I'm new to Yamamoto, but I always see his stuff in the cool corners of the manga floors of the biggest bookstores - that corner by the elevator in the basement of the Ikebukuro Junkudo - I bought this purely on a flyer. Sometimes you get lucky.
It's fine stuff. It's sexy, sure, but also by turns creepy, nostalgic, funny, wistful, hard-boiled, satirical, socially engaged, and even innocent. There's always two or three things going on alongside the wet stuff; usually something to make the wet stuff even wetter, and something else to make it bone dry.
The writing's great, and the art rises to the occasion, too. He's more daring, or is allowed to be freer, than most artists who draw this kind of stuff for mass-market publications in Japan, but what makes his wet stuff work is, of course, not just their cunning lubricity, but his sensitive and sure touch with everything else in the visual plane. His framing, his composition, his line and shade, are all masterful; and he experiments. There's one story in here told entirely in long-focus and wide-frame, same angle, panel after panel, like a movie camera set up and turned on and left; it's not a trick he came up with (I've seen it in Tezuka, for example), but neither is it a common one, and he uses it well.
It's adult in every sense of the word.
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
Fujino Kaori, Tsume to me
The 149th Akutagawa Prize, for the first half of 2013, went to Fujino Kaori 藤野可織 for the story Tsume to me 爪と目 (Nails and eyes).
The obi blurb calls it "a chilling work of literary horror" (戦慄な純文学的恐怖さく, with 恐怖作 glossed ホラー). I'm not sure if I'm glad I knew that or not. Knowing that, I was looking for it to get suspenseful, or scary, or creepy, uncanny, or something somewhat resembling horror. So when we learn that the mother is dead in mysterious circumstances, cause of death unknown, I automatically suspected the daughter. And, in turn, that led me to expect something very like the final scene.
But I get ahead of myself. The basic story is this: a young woman, presumably in her 20s, who works at a temp agency, is having an affair with a married man who's temporarily stationed in a different city from his wife and young daughter. The wife dies (in mysterious circumstances, cause of death unknown), and not long after that the guy asks his mistress to marry him. She agrees to move in with him for six months on a trial basis. Most of the story concerns her gradually getting used to being a house-not-quite-wife: quitting her job, learning to take care of the little girl, furnishing the apartment. Gradually shifting from a thoughtless floating single existence to an uneasily tethered existence. Meanwhile, the little girl is, understandably, traumatized by the death of her mother; this manifests itself in near-catatonic passivity coupled with severe nail-biting. Eventually the mistress takes a lover; she also starts haunting homemaker blogs, eventually discovering the one that had been maintained by the mother. She starts to furnish the new apartment exactly like the old. This is all interrupted one day when the lover comes over unexpectedly, and the mistress hides the daughter on the veranda, locks the glass door, and pulls the curtains. This traumatizes the daughter (her mother had died locked out on the veranda). Later she takes her revenge by placing fingernail clippings on the mistress's eyes while she's sleeping and pressing... The end.
In literary-technique terms, there's one big curveball in all this. The story is narrated in what amounts to the second person. Not a complete second person narration like Bright Lights Big City (the only example I can think of, actually). It's narrated in the voice of the daughter, who is an adult of unspecified age as she's narrating, and who is addressing the mistress. But it feels almost like a complete second person narration, because we're not privy to the thoughts of the daughter (despite the fact that it's her narrating), while we are privy to the thoughts of the mistress. In other words, the main character of the story is "you" (anata), and we're told what "you" were thinking at any given moment; but although an "I" does show up from time to time, we're not really told what "I" was thinking. Nor do we know why "I" is speaking at the present moment, nor do we know much about the present moment at all. This isn't a confession - it's not "I" finally explaining to "you" decades later why she did what she did (either "she"). Curious effect.
As I say, my experience of the story was entirely colored by the fact that it's billed as literary horror. The death of the mother is presented as a mystery. Her body is discovered frozen on the veranda, with the glass door locked from the inside and the daughter asleep in the bedroom. Did she commit suicide? Accidentally lock herself out - unlikely, from the construction of the lock? Did the daughter kill her? The horror-story billing makes us suspect the daughter; and this, as I say, in turn makes us suspect that the daughter is going to do something to the mistress, and she does.
But just what she does is a little unclear. Does she blind the mistress? One of the very few references to the present day in the story makes it clear that daughter and mistress have been living together as mother and daughter, and mentions the mistress clinging to the daughter's arm as an adult just like the daughter clung to the mistress's arm as a child. So is the mistress blinded by the girl's fingernails? Or just wounded? And if she's blinded, why does she marry the guy and stay with the daughter after the six months are up?
One possible explanation for this comes in the way the mistress seems to gradually become possessed by the spirit of the mother through her blog... No, that's overstating it. If this had been a real, determined horror story, that's what would have happened. But we're give no indication that a supernatural thing is happening there. Rather, it's presented in a literary way, i.e., a suggestion that in her alienation and lostness the mistress is sinking into a traditional gender role with uneasy inevitability, that her identity as an individual is becoming submerged into her role as wife and mother. However, this role is not presented as one of tenderness or nurturing - her way of dealing with the kid's nail-biting is to give her junk food to nibble on - but rather one of consumption. Buying things to make the house neat. Fashionable furniture. The wife had done that - her blog consisted basically of photos of furniture, as if that were a stand-in for her missing inner life.
The only moment of tenderness the mistress displays toward the daughter is right before the eye-scratching scene. The girl has scratched other kids at school with her bitten-jagged nails, and a scolding from the school moves the mistress to give the girl's nails a good trim and paint them with nail varnish. Is this her finally accepting her role as mother? So that when the daughter scratches her, the mistress decides to stay and help her rather than flee and leave her to her misery?
May be.
Set out like that, the story makes a certain amount of sense to me on both a literary and a horror-story level (as if those had to be opposed; I don't believe they do, for the record). However, I feel like in setting it out like that I've made a few connections that I really think the writer should have made. Leaving things for the reader to figure out is one thing, but let's just say I'm not sure that this reading is justified by what's actually on the page; and yet, at the same time, it's not indeterminate in a particularly productive or moving way, either. I keep coming back to this, but if it weren't for the warning that this should be read as horror, I don't think I would have detected any tension at all until the very end; and that applies to narrative tension, as well. The story feels trivial and aimless, up to the end.
There's promise here, but I'm not sure there's excellence. On the other hand as a choice for the A-Prize it seems pretty comprehensible. This will be much less divisive than the last choice, not to mention much more accessible.
The book contains two other stories, Shōko-san ga wasureteiru koto しょう子さんが忘れていること "What Shōko-san Is Forgetting" and Chibikko hiroba ちびっこ広場 "Kiddy Plaza." Both share the title story's interest in unsettled minds and unsettling moods, not quite to say horror.
"Shōko-san" is told from the point of view of a woman in her 80s who has had a stroke and is in rehab for it. Every night in bed she's visited by a mysterious man who does things to her, and every day she forgets it. Sometimes during the day her daughter and grown granddaughter visit, and the granddaughter takes a liking to a young male patient who's always hanging around. Can you see where this is going? At the end Shōko-san seems to realize that it's this young male patient who's been visiting her, and that he's probably been doing sexual things to her. But the narration is locked into Shōko-san's dreamlike consciousness, so none of the details of any of it are clear.
"Kiddy Plaza" is a little neater. A young mother is getting ready for a night out with the girls, when her little boy comes home from the playground crying. She thinks he just doesn't want her to go out, so she waits until her husband comes home and hands him over. But when she gets home and he's still crying she learns that the kids have told him the playground is cursed. Anybody who's there at 4:44 will be visited in the night by a girl who invites him to go to the playground. Finally the mother tells him she'll convince him that it's nonsense. Come on, let's go to the playground...
That one I kind of liked.
Sunday, August 4, 2013
Sunshine Daydream
We were out of the country for much of July, coming back the day after the Country Fair ended. So for the first time in three years, I didn't go, and you, Gentle Readers, were spared a long navel-gazing post about hippies. Time for a break anyway, though.
*
But then I saw Sunshine Daydream a few days ago. This is a movie made about a Grateful Dead concert in 1972. The concert has been legendary among Dead fans ever since, in the sense that it has circulated widely and been widely hailed as one of their best shows ever (The Deadhead's Taping Compendium makes a serious case, over several pages, for it as a religious experience). The film has also been legendary, but in a different sense: it was never released, and most Heads have only known it as a rumor, or as a grainy multi-generational VHS dub, or youtube of same. More myth than reality. But the Dead's organization have finally cleaned it up, remastered it, and are releasing both the audio of the show and a DVD of the movie, and to plug it they did a satellite simulcast of the film to theaters around the country this past week on Jerry's birthday.
It so happens that this show took place in Veneta, at the site of what was then a Renaissance Fair, which later became the Oregon Country Fair. So seeing this film in Springfield (at the only local theater receiving it) meant that I was seeing it in the company, not just of a lot of Eugene's trademark hippies, but of people who had been there, and seeing it as close as you could get to where it happened. And of course I've been to the Fairgrounds, stood on that field, thought to myself, this is where it happened. Hell, when we moved here I was even excited to realize that Nancy's Yogurt is an actual ongoing thing (and it's pretty damn good yogurt, too).
So, you know, if I couldn't make it to the OCF this year, this was the next best thing, and maybe in some ways better, in terms of getting my annual dose of hippie wannabe nostalgia...
*
It turns out to be a pretty great film.
The actual filming is a little variable - the footage of "Sing Me Back Home," the last song, gets kind of unwatchable because it was getting dark and the filmmakers didn't have the right film or lighting equipment. The interspersal of 1966 performance footage, and Furthur bus film, is interesting but was utterly baffling to the uninitiated (such as Mrs. Sgt. T), because totally unexplained, just dropped in without warning. And the animation in the middle of "Dark Star" is interesting, but ultimately not quite as interesting as it would have been to just keep showing us the band.
On the other hand it captures the eventness of the event pretty well (I say, not having been there). It makes you feel the heat, and at the same time the lushness of the Veneta countryside, and the utter freedom of the scene. Which is maybe a euphemism for saying it has a lot of naked hippies dancing in a field under the sun near some trees. A lot. And when it comes right down to it, if that sounds fun to you, you'll probably like this film. And if not, not.
But as much as I liked that aspect of the film (and I did indeed, in spite/because of the fact that I wouldn't have had the courage to get naked and dance myself), it's the music, and the way the music is presented, that makes it worth seeing.
Here too there are limitations - only a couple of shots of Keith Godchaux, for example, which broke my heart because he's clearly audible on the soundtrack, playing brilliantly. The filmmakers caught the other members, though, and show them playing - long, nicely focused shots of players playing. Sometimes we get their fingers, and if I was a guitar player I'm sure that would please me; other times we just get their faces, which in some ways is more interesting, because I can't help but wonder what it would feel like to be able to play like that. But often we get several members at once, and that's where we get the magic of ensemble playing, right there on screen. You can see them nodding at each other, grimacing or smiling at what the others are doing, signalling each other.
Or, more tellingly, not signalling each other. The musical high point is, of course, the "Dark Star," a magnificent piece of ensemble playing. Utterly musical - if your image of the Dead is of aimless noodling, then, well, let's just say you're way wrong, and this "Dark Star" might show you why. It's jamming, mostly without vocals, but always with a purpose, always with a direction - they're not just drifting, they're moving through a succession of musical moods and settings with careful attention to what they're doing now, and a good sense of where they might go next. It's anything but stagnant.
And it's also, in true Dead fashion, anything but lead-and-comping. They're all soloing at once - Jerry's lines can sound like a lead guitar, but often only in the sense that he's providing the most obvious musical anchor, giving everybody else the freedom to embroider even more creatively. And when they move, they all move together, without missing a beat or a shade or a grace note. And that's where the film is so brilliant, because for long minutes of this "Dark Star" (when it's not weird animation), we're watching the band, and we realize that they're not really watching each other. No one of them is catching the others' eyes, giving directions, signalling. They're just listening to each other, and that's enough. It's really phenomenal. And of course it's something any Deadhead knows the band could do. But I've never seen it caught visually so well.
I doubt anybody who doesn't already get the Dead could make it through this film. Which is a shame, because more than any other, I think it shows why those of us who love them for their music (as opposed to What They Represented, or whatever) love them.
*
So I saw that Thursday night, and most of the day Friday I was still in this great glow, having seen my annual quota of naked dancing hippies, having remembered (after a few weeks of not really listening to them) why I love the Dead, and having come to a deeper appreciation of how very right it feels to me that I've come to live in this place.
And then I read this. Some background. That blog is one I read regularly. It's maybe my third or fourth morning read. And what sets it apart, for me, is that author's particular point of view - his subject position, to use a dated piece of academic parlance. He's a solid leftist with a particular interest in and sympathy for labor unions, an interest that manifests itself in his work as a historian of the labor movement in this country but that has its roots, as he frequently reminds us, in his upbringing in the very working-class town of Springfield, Oregon. To me that's all to the good: not only does he provide me food for thought from a congenial political point of view, not only does he educate me on aspects of the left that I'm not as familiar with as I should be, but he helps me better understand the community I live in (even though he doesn't live here anymore). Cool.
But God, what a dick he's being in that post, right? And more so in the comments. Now, I get it: there are cultural tensions between Eugene and Springfield that pretty neatly mirror the major cultural tensions in the American left as a whole. Intellectual vs. working class, environment vs. industry, college vs. factory (or sawmill), New Left vs. Old Left. Spotted owls vs. loggers. Hippies vs. blue-collars. And I'm entirely willing to allow that Loomis might have scars from his childhood here; we all carry that kind of baggage. So I can forgive him being a dick, a troll (it's his blog, right), and whatever.
I'm more saddened by how ready we on the Left are to break into warring tribes: it's the old circular firing squad, the Fractured Left meme, and it's exactly what They want us to be doing. Which we know - even Loomis knows it, or I should say especially him, because he's out there fighting the good fight, trying to remind the Left what it has spent the last few decades forgetting, that it doesn't win without labor, and in fact that labor rights are human rights.
United we stand, in other words. But all that goes by the board when there's a chance to point and laugh at hippies. I've never understood this. I've seen it for decades, from precisely the people who should know better. I spent part of my sophomore year in high school in an ongoing argument with a punk girl, trying to convince her that hippies weren't the enemy, that we were all on the same side, had more in common than not, that we'd be better off allying to fight the real enemy. Never worked. So we get people like Loomis, who, instead of welcoming people to the Left no matter what their motivation, or failing that, instead of, you know, live and let live, points and laughs. Like a dick.
Because that's all he's doing, is pointing and laughing. There's no reasoned argument in there that X political approach is ineffective, or that Y lifestyle is actually pernicious in some way; there can't be reasoned argument, because he's not bothering to address any actual thing. He just says "hippies," and the other bullies all know what he means.
*
But then I saw Sunshine Daydream a few days ago. This is a movie made about a Grateful Dead concert in 1972. The concert has been legendary among Dead fans ever since, in the sense that it has circulated widely and been widely hailed as one of their best shows ever (The Deadhead's Taping Compendium makes a serious case, over several pages, for it as a religious experience). The film has also been legendary, but in a different sense: it was never released, and most Heads have only known it as a rumor, or as a grainy multi-generational VHS dub, or youtube of same. More myth than reality. But the Dead's organization have finally cleaned it up, remastered it, and are releasing both the audio of the show and a DVD of the movie, and to plug it they did a satellite simulcast of the film to theaters around the country this past week on Jerry's birthday.
It so happens that this show took place in Veneta, at the site of what was then a Renaissance Fair, which later became the Oregon Country Fair. So seeing this film in Springfield (at the only local theater receiving it) meant that I was seeing it in the company, not just of a lot of Eugene's trademark hippies, but of people who had been there, and seeing it as close as you could get to where it happened. And of course I've been to the Fairgrounds, stood on that field, thought to myself, this is where it happened. Hell, when we moved here I was even excited to realize that Nancy's Yogurt is an actual ongoing thing (and it's pretty damn good yogurt, too).
So, you know, if I couldn't make it to the OCF this year, this was the next best thing, and maybe in some ways better, in terms of getting my annual dose of hippie wannabe nostalgia...
*
It turns out to be a pretty great film.
The actual filming is a little variable - the footage of "Sing Me Back Home," the last song, gets kind of unwatchable because it was getting dark and the filmmakers didn't have the right film or lighting equipment. The interspersal of 1966 performance footage, and Furthur bus film, is interesting but was utterly baffling to the uninitiated (such as Mrs. Sgt. T), because totally unexplained, just dropped in without warning. And the animation in the middle of "Dark Star" is interesting, but ultimately not quite as interesting as it would have been to just keep showing us the band.
On the other hand it captures the eventness of the event pretty well (I say, not having been there). It makes you feel the heat, and at the same time the lushness of the Veneta countryside, and the utter freedom of the scene. Which is maybe a euphemism for saying it has a lot of naked hippies dancing in a field under the sun near some trees. A lot. And when it comes right down to it, if that sounds fun to you, you'll probably like this film. And if not, not.
But as much as I liked that aspect of the film (and I did indeed, in spite/because of the fact that I wouldn't have had the courage to get naked and dance myself), it's the music, and the way the music is presented, that makes it worth seeing.
Here too there are limitations - only a couple of shots of Keith Godchaux, for example, which broke my heart because he's clearly audible on the soundtrack, playing brilliantly. The filmmakers caught the other members, though, and show them playing - long, nicely focused shots of players playing. Sometimes we get their fingers, and if I was a guitar player I'm sure that would please me; other times we just get their faces, which in some ways is more interesting, because I can't help but wonder what it would feel like to be able to play like that. But often we get several members at once, and that's where we get the magic of ensemble playing, right there on screen. You can see them nodding at each other, grimacing or smiling at what the others are doing, signalling each other.
Or, more tellingly, not signalling each other. The musical high point is, of course, the "Dark Star," a magnificent piece of ensemble playing. Utterly musical - if your image of the Dead is of aimless noodling, then, well, let's just say you're way wrong, and this "Dark Star" might show you why. It's jamming, mostly without vocals, but always with a purpose, always with a direction - they're not just drifting, they're moving through a succession of musical moods and settings with careful attention to what they're doing now, and a good sense of where they might go next. It's anything but stagnant.
And it's also, in true Dead fashion, anything but lead-and-comping. They're all soloing at once - Jerry's lines can sound like a lead guitar, but often only in the sense that he's providing the most obvious musical anchor, giving everybody else the freedom to embroider even more creatively. And when they move, they all move together, without missing a beat or a shade or a grace note. And that's where the film is so brilliant, because for long minutes of this "Dark Star" (when it's not weird animation), we're watching the band, and we realize that they're not really watching each other. No one of them is catching the others' eyes, giving directions, signalling. They're just listening to each other, and that's enough. It's really phenomenal. And of course it's something any Deadhead knows the band could do. But I've never seen it caught visually so well.
I doubt anybody who doesn't already get the Dead could make it through this film. Which is a shame, because more than any other, I think it shows why those of us who love them for their music (as opposed to What They Represented, or whatever) love them.
*
So I saw that Thursday night, and most of the day Friday I was still in this great glow, having seen my annual quota of naked dancing hippies, having remembered (after a few weeks of not really listening to them) why I love the Dead, and having come to a deeper appreciation of how very right it feels to me that I've come to live in this place.
And then I read this. Some background. That blog is one I read regularly. It's maybe my third or fourth morning read. And what sets it apart, for me, is that author's particular point of view - his subject position, to use a dated piece of academic parlance. He's a solid leftist with a particular interest in and sympathy for labor unions, an interest that manifests itself in his work as a historian of the labor movement in this country but that has its roots, as he frequently reminds us, in his upbringing in the very working-class town of Springfield, Oregon. To me that's all to the good: not only does he provide me food for thought from a congenial political point of view, not only does he educate me on aspects of the left that I'm not as familiar with as I should be, but he helps me better understand the community I live in (even though he doesn't live here anymore). Cool.
But God, what a dick he's being in that post, right? And more so in the comments. Now, I get it: there are cultural tensions between Eugene and Springfield that pretty neatly mirror the major cultural tensions in the American left as a whole. Intellectual vs. working class, environment vs. industry, college vs. factory (or sawmill), New Left vs. Old Left. Spotted owls vs. loggers. Hippies vs. blue-collars. And I'm entirely willing to allow that Loomis might have scars from his childhood here; we all carry that kind of baggage. So I can forgive him being a dick, a troll (it's his blog, right), and whatever.
I'm more saddened by how ready we on the Left are to break into warring tribes: it's the old circular firing squad, the Fractured Left meme, and it's exactly what They want us to be doing. Which we know - even Loomis knows it, or I should say especially him, because he's out there fighting the good fight, trying to remind the Left what it has spent the last few decades forgetting, that it doesn't win without labor, and in fact that labor rights are human rights.
United we stand, in other words. But all that goes by the board when there's a chance to point and laugh at hippies. I've never understood this. I've seen it for decades, from precisely the people who should know better. I spent part of my sophomore year in high school in an ongoing argument with a punk girl, trying to convince her that hippies weren't the enemy, that we were all on the same side, had more in common than not, that we'd be better off allying to fight the real enemy. Never worked. So we get people like Loomis, who, instead of welcoming people to the Left no matter what their motivation, or failing that, instead of, you know, live and let live, points and laughs. Like a dick.
Because that's all he's doing, is pointing and laughing. There's no reasoned argument in there that X political approach is ineffective, or that Y lifestyle is actually pernicious in some way; there can't be reasoned argument, because he's not bothering to address any actual thing. He just says "hippies," and the other bullies all know what he means.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




